The debate over the true independence of internal audit (IA) has resurfaced with new urgency following the recent high-profile firings of multiple inspectors general (IGs). Government IGs in the United States operate in similar ways to IA in private-sector organizations. Given their similarity, these IG dismissals have sparked controversy within the IA community, with critics arguing they threaten government oversight and accountability. The situation underscores a long-standing issue: IA and IGs are not truly independent, and continuing to believe otherwise does more harm than good.